Fall TV Scorecard: What’s Been Renewed and Canceled So Far, Plus Our Predictions

Fall TV is my favorite time of year! There are so many new shows to watch and so many shows to, well, not. It’s a fun game we play of which shows will get renewed, which shows get canceled, and which shows we think will get canceled but get renewed. (Ahem *cough cough* The Neighbors.) Anyways, here is a list of my predictions of shows that are most likely going to be canceled, along with what’s already been canceled so you know what to stop recording. Let us know your thoughts on your favorite new shows and which ones you want to be picked up for another season!

What’s Been Picked Up

The Blacklist - Season 1
Photo Credit: Will Hart / NBC

  • The Blacklist: NBC’s hit drama starring James Spader was picked up for a full 22 episodes

  • Sleepy Hollow: FOX’s mystery has already been renewed for a second season

  • The Crazy Ones: CBS has picked up the comedy starring Robin Williams and Sarah Michelle Gellar for a full season

  • Marvel’s Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.: ABC picked up the series for a full season

  • The Millers: CBS’ family sitcom starring Will Arnett was picked up for the whole season

  • Brooklyn Nine-Nine: FOX gave the Andy Samberg comedy a full season pickup*

  • Mom: CBS’ series starring funny girl Anna Faris earned a whole season*

  • Dads: FOX’s comedy has been picked up for a full season (only because they don’t have a lot of comedies left and have to ride it out)*

What’s Been Canceled

We Are Learning to SwimPhoto Credit: CBS

  • Ironside starring Blair Underwood has been canceled (NBC)

  • We Are Men: Canceled after two episodes (CBS)

  • Welcome to the Family starring Mike O’Malley has been canceled (NBC)

  • Lucky 7: ABC’s low-rated drama was canceled after two episodes

Soon to be Canceled Shows – Predictions

Photo credit: Peter “Hopper” Stone / ABC


Sean Saves the World – Unfortunately NBC has yet another comedy that isn’t doing well ratings-wise. Even Sean Hayes said that NBC “just doesn’t have the eyeballs” to make his show a hit, and it would’ve been better on CBS. That doesn’t bode well for the Peacock. 

Revolution started out as a promising show for the network but hasn’t really made a comeback from last season. The show about life in a post-blackout world has garnered a series low of 1.4 in adults 18-49 over the last two weeks, and yet the network is saying tonight’s episode “is the one everyone will be talking about tomorrow.” Unfortunately for them, it’s up against game six in the World Series, so we’ll see.


Beauty and the Beast was definitely a talked-about show before the series began last year. Personally, I was excited for the show, as I loved the original and I’m a sucker for all things CW. However, that didn’t really work out. Now don’t get me wrong, I’m still watching it for some weird reason, but let’s face it, it’s not the best show in the world. It’s one of their lowest rated shows andwas even at the bottom of Ad Age’s annual survey on what 30-second commercials cost on all the networks. Don’t expect this show to last. It’s definitely at the top of the list to be canceled.

The Carrie Diaries was one of my favorite pilots last season. I was so looking forward to this trip back in time for Carrie Bradshaw, and excited to see how she met the rest of the gang. Unfortunately, it didn’t really work out. The show wasn’t what I wanted it to be. Sure, it had the music and the clothes, but the show itself wasn’t that great. I know you’re probably thinking, “but it was renewed last year with such low ratings?!” Yes, that’s true, but I don’t think the network would do it again.


Super Fun Night was bad to begin with. It all started with Rebel Wilson wanting to play an American, and let’s face it, she is trying so hard to keep the accent that her acting chops go downhill. Just like Jesse Spencer on Chicago Fire. He’s a great actor and was amazing on House, but is trying so hard to stay with his American accent that it makes him seem like a horrible actor. But that’s not the only problem, it’s just the main one. The show isn’t that well written, and frankly, it’s quite boring. It premiered with strong ratings but was given the boost brought on by ABC’s super hit Modern Family. Yes, I know they ordered additional scripts, but that doesn’t mean it will be a given a second season renewal. I could be wrong, but I definitely stopped recording it after the second episode.

Betrayal is one of those silly ABC shows, like Mistresses, that I thought would be fun and cheesy and would totally watch and enjoy. Now, I am recording and watching, but it’s basically background noise. There are some amazing actors in this show, including James Cromwell and Stuart Townsend, but that’s not enough to keep a show going. The writing is horrible and yet somehow, the show outperformed CBS’ The Good Wife/The Mentalist with women 18-34. It could definitely be like Mistresses and shock everyone with a second season renewal, but I won’t hold my breath.   

Trophy Wife was one of my favorite pilots this fall season. Hmmm, I’m sensing a theme here. Anyways, Malin Akerman is absolutely adorable in this family comedy that no one is watching. According to TVByTheNumbers, “it’s ABC’s lowest rated non-Friday sitcom by a fair margin,” and they’re guessing that ABC might bring in Suburgatory to take its place. The show garnered a 1.4, up 17% from last week’s series low of 1.2 adults 18-49, but it’s still on the train headed towards cancelation.


CBS showed a sneak peek of Hostages during the upfronts earlier this year, and everyone, I mean everyone, was on the edge of their seat. It was as if we had been watching all season, when in fact it had only been a 4 minute reel. Dylan McDermott, Toni Collette and Tate Donavan! I mean, what more could you ask for in a show? Well, I guess a better show. I totally forgot to watch it after that. It just wasn’t that exciting in the end. How long could it go on for? I mean, she should just call the police! Or talk to Secret Service about what’s happening instead of not doing anything. But then again, I stopped watching, so maybe she did.

Ohhhhh…Dads. Where do I start? This show was NOT funny and was totally racist. Sure sure, I get Seth MacFarlane’s humor. Believe me, I LOVE Family Guy, but this is not that. FOX isn’t having a great season and this show isn’t helping. The network recently ordered additional episodes, but remember, that doesn’t mean it’s getting picked up for a second season. They’re having the same issues with Brooklyn Nine-Nine, and The Mindy Project isn’t doing that well either. The only reason they would keep Dads is because they have nothing else. Almost Human is premiering later next month (keeps getting pushed multiple times), and Enlisted isn’t going to do much as far as ratings go either. So if you’re attached to Dads, good luck sir, because I don’t think this one will last.  

*Being picked up for a full season doesn’t mean that show has been renewed for 2014

Leave a Reply